Differences between Light and Electron Microscope

Differences between Light and Electron Microscope

Both light microscopes and electron microscopes use radiation (light or electron beams) to form larger and more detailed images of objects which cannot be seen clearly through an unaided eye.

Differences between Light and Electron Microscope

However, each of these microscopes has distinct features and is suitable for different purposes.

S.N.

Character

Light Microscope

Electron Microscope
1.       Alternatively known as Optical microscope Beam microscope
2.       Invented by It is believed that Dutch spectacles makers Zacharius Jansen and his father Hans were the first to invent the compound microscope in the 16th century. In 1931 physicist Ernst Ruska and German engineer Max Knoll.
3.       Illuminating source Uses light (approx wavelength 400-700 nm) to illuminate the objects under view. Uses a beam of electrons (approx equivalent wavelength 1 nm) to make objects larger for a detailed view.
4.       Principle Image formed by absorption of light waves. Image formed by scattering or transmission of electrons.
5.       Structure Light microscopes are smaller and lighter. Heavier and larger in size.
6.       Lenses used Lenses are made of glass. Lenses are made of electromagnets.
7.       Vacuum Not used under a vacuum Operates under a high vacuum
8.       Specimen type Fixed or un-fixed, stained or unstained, living or non-living. Fixed, stained and non-living.
9.       Specimen observed Both live and dead specimens can be observed. Only dead specimens are possible to be observed.
10.    Specimen preparation Less tedious and simple. Generally involves harsher processes, e.g. using corrosive chemicals. More skill required – both to prepare specimens and to interpret EM images (due to artefacts).
11.    Preparation time Specimen preparation takes usually few minutes to hours. Specimen preparation takes usually takes few days.
12.    Thickness of specimen 5 micrometer or thicker Ultra-thin, 0.1 micrometer or below
13.    Dehydration of Specimen Specimen need not be dehydrated before viewing. Only dehydrated specimens are used.
14.    Coating of specimen Stained by colored dyes for proper visualization. Coated with heavy metals to reflect electrons.
15.    Mounting of specimen Mounted on glass slide. Mounted on metallic grid (mostly copper).
16.    Focusing Done by adjusting the lens position mechanically. Done by adjusting the power of electric current to the electromagnetic lenses.
17.    Magnification power Low magnification of up to 1,500x. High magnification of up to 1,000,000x.
18.    Resolving power Low resolving power, usually below 0.30µm.  High resolving power of up to 0.001µm, about 250 times higher than light microscope.
19.    Viewing of image formed Light microscope images can be viewed directly. Images are viewed by the eyes through the eyepiece. Images are viewed on a photographic plate or zinc sulphate fluorescent screen.
20.    Nature of Image formed Poor surface view Good surface view and internal details
21.     Image Color Colored images. Electron microscopes produce grayscale (sometimes called “black and white”) images (except “false-color” electron micrographs).
22.    Image dimension Image plane “flat” (2D). 2D only in Transmission electron microscope (TEM); 
Scanning electron Microscope (SEM) images gives depth information which seems like 3D.
23.    Living processes Visualization of living processes such as microscopic pond life in action, and even cell division is possible. Living processes cannot be viewed.
24.    Room settings No special settings required. Must be used in a room where humidity, pressure and temperature are controlled.
25.    Simplicity in use Simple to use Users require technical skills
26.    Electric Current No need for high voltage electricity. High voltage electric current is required (50,000 V or above).
27.    Filaments No filaments used. Tungsten filaments used to generate electrons.
28.    Cooling System Absent Cooling system present to pacify the heat generated due to high voltage electric current.
29.    Radiation leakage No radiation risk. Risk of radiation leakage.
30.    Complexity Less complex Complex
31.    Expense Cheap to buy and has low maintenance costs. Very expensive to buy as well as to maintain.
32.    Suitability /   Practicality Suitable for most basic functions, and is very common in schools and other learning institutions. Limited to specialized use such as research.
33.    Advantages
  • Easy to use
  • Cheap
  • True color but sometimes require staining
  • Live specimens 
  • High resolution
  • Provide detailed images of surface structures and interior structures
  • High magnification
  • 3D images
34.    Disadvantages
  • Low resolution due to shorter wavelength of light (0.2nm)
  • Low magnification
  • Specimen used is thin.
  • Expensive
  • Requires extensive training
  • Sample must be dead
  • Black and white/false color image
35.    Types/ Variants
  • Dark-field microscope
  • Phase contrast microscope
  • Fluorescent microscope
    Confocal microscope
    Polarized microscope
  • Differential interference contrast microscope
  • Transmission electron microscope (TEM)
  • Scanning electron Microscope (SEM)
36.    Application It is used for the study of detailed gross internal structure. It is used in the study of external surface, ultra structure of cell and very small organisms.

References

  1. Manandhar S. (2013). A practical approach to microbiology. Revised 2nd Edition. National Book Centre: Kathmandu.
  2. https://theydiffer.com/difference-between-a-light-microscope-and-an-electron-microscope/
  3. https://www.majordifferences.com/2013/10/difference-between-electron-microscope.html
  4. http://www.ivyroses.com/Biology/Techniques/light-microscope-vs-electron-microscope.php
  5. https://biodifferences.com/difference-between-light-microscope-and-electron-microscope.html
  6. https://www.easybiologyclass.com/light-microscope-vs-electron-microscope-similarities-differences-comparison-table/

Differences between Light and Electron Microscope

(Visited 3,936 times, 10 visits today)

Leave a Comment